Publicly-owned rail may not get us back on right track
The Independent|November 20, 2024
Nationalisation is often touted as a golden ticket to a better train service. Simon Calder is less optimistic it will work
Simon Calder
Publicly-owned rail may not get us back on right track

“Britain’s railways are broken.” So says – or said – the transport secretary, Louise Haigh. Her social media assessment of the dire state of the rail industry, made six weeks ahead of the general election in July, remains true today. “Cancellations have soared to record levels, fares have risen almost twice as fast as wages, and taxpayers are paying through the teeth to prop up a failing system.” Ms Haigh spelled out what she intended to do about it: “Labour will deliver a publicly-owned railway that puts the passenger first.”

Rail nationalisation is an undoubted vote-winner. For anyone who can remember the 2019 election, it was one manifesto promise from Jeremy Corbyn that was popular with a majority of voters.

For all of us passengers who feel let down by the railways, bringing trains back under state control sounds tempting. Baroness Blake of Leeds, the Labour peer who is steering the Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Bill through the House of Lords, says: “Public ownership will allow us to end the failed franchising system which has inflicted misery on passengers through delays, overcrowding, and poor service.”

“This bill will ensure that trains are run for the benefit of the British public, not for the profits of shareholders around the world.”

This story is from the November 20, 2024 edition of The Independent.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the November 20, 2024 edition of The Independent.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM THE INDEPENDENTView All
Council squeezes homeless family into a one-bed flat
The Independent

Council squeezes homeless family into a one-bed flat

A mother of two has been forced to sleep with her daughter in their living room for over a year after a London council put the homeless family in a one-bed flat. S

time-read
3 mins  |
March 06, 2025
Rishi reflects on his biggest mistakes in Downing Street
The Independent

Rishi reflects on his biggest mistakes in Downing Street

Rishi Sunak has spoken for the first time about his relatively brief and challenging time as prime minister, his record on migration, and his pledge to stop the boats”.

time-read
2 mins  |
March 06, 2025
US tariffs will push down growth’ in blow to Reeves
The Independent

US tariffs will push down growth’ in blow to Reeves

Donald Trump’s plans to impose tariffs on US imports will shrink the British economy, Rachel Reeves has been warned by Britain’s top economists.

time-read
3 mins  |
March 06, 2025
Almost half of Britons want Trump state visit cancelled
The Independent

Almost half of Britons want Trump state visit cancelled

Poll shows anger at US president over stance on Ukraine

time-read
2 mins  |
March 06, 2025
Rapist may have attacked scores of women, say police
The Independent

Rapist may have attacked scores of women, say police

A serial sex predator is suspected of raping more than 60 women while studying in London, as the Met Police launch an urgent appeal for victim-survivors.

time-read
4 mins  |
March 06, 2025
Man wins 700,000 battle over mother’s deathbed will
The Independent

Man wins 700,000 battle over mother’s deathbed will

An electrician has won a 700,000 will fight after a video emerged of his younger sister holding and propelling” their dying mother’s hand as she signed over her fortune on her deathbed.

time-read
5 mins  |
March 06, 2025
Meet the six rookies racing to the future on the F1 grid
The Independent

Meet the six rookies racing to the future on the F1 grid

Last year was all about the old guard. Now Kieran Jackson savours what’s in store from a young, quick new generation

time-read
4 mins  |
March 06, 2025
Justice secretary opposes two-tier’ sentencing plans
The Independent

Justice secretary opposes two-tier’ sentencing plans

The justice secretary is calling for new guidance for judges to consider a defendant’s ethnicity when deciding whether to send them to prison to be reversed over concerns of two-tier sentencing”.

time-read
2 mins  |
March 06, 2025
‘Austerity chancellor’ plans to cut billions from welfare
The Independent

‘Austerity chancellor’ plans to cut billions from welfare

Rachel Reeves is planning billions of pounds of cuts to benefits and other public spending ahead of this month’s spring statement, it has emerged.

time-read
4 mins  |
March 06, 2025
Royal Ballet breathes new life into Romeo and Juliet
The Independent

Royal Ballet breathes new life into Romeo and Juliet

Decades on, Kenneth MacMillan’s classic production still has the power to move audiences. Zoe Anderson swoons

time-read
2 mins  |
March 06, 2025