It is a case of perverted sexuality, torture and death caused by breakage of the thyroid cartilage due to throttling.
The media initially reported this as a gangrape due to the alleged presence of a large amount of seminal fluid collected from the corpus of the deceased during autopsy. However, more recent reports indicated that the DNA collected has established the involvement of only one accused: Sanjoy Roy, a civic volunteer. In fact, the '151 mg liquid' mentioned in the post-mortem report was misinterpreted due to a lack of forensic awareness.
Undue delays in conducting forensic analysis in such cases create doubts about manipulation, depleting faith in the administration of justice. The recent Anokhilal case in Madhya Pradesh was a glaring case of forensic misconduct, leading to a man receiving the death sentence twice at two trials where the DNA report was misinterpreted as inculpatory evidence. Forensic misconduct was exposed only during the third trial and on March 19, 2024, it became the first DNA-based exoneration in India.
From July 2024, India replaced three major criminal laws and placed high reliance on forensic investigation. However, certain precautions are necessary, as forensic opinion is not gospel truth. The science behind forensics may be perfect, but the man behind forensic procedures may not be. When misconduct couples with collusion, fraud is inevitable; forensics is no exception.
This story is from the August 30, 2024 edition of The Morning Standard.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the August 30, 2024 edition of The Morning Standard.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
CABINET STAMP ON 'ONE POLL'SCHEME
Implementation group to be formed to take it forward
Not much wriggle room on external debt for next Sri Lankan President
Sri Lanka's two presidential frontrunners have pledged to renegotiate the agreement with the International Monetary Fund (IMF), increase social security and ease people's financial burdens, but experts say major deviations may not be feasible though it is possible to chip away at the edges.
Multi-storey building collapses in Karol Bagh; 4 killed, 14 hurt
FOUR people were killed, while 14 others sustained injuries after a portion of a multi-storey building collapsed in the Karol Bagh area on Wednesday morning, a senior police official said.
Bottled sentiments
GOWING up, my everyday school tiffin would include only one standard meal of paratha and achaar.
STARTING OVER AGAIN
SOPHIE Deraspe's Canadian-French film Bergers (English title Shepherds) is about the existential angst and latent desires of many city-slickers who find themselves on a perennial treadmill when it comes to their profession.
STYLISH SYMPHONY IN SARIS
LEANING gently against the tanpura, her eyes closed, we see a series of photographs of a legend gracefully immersed in her melody.
India win fifth ACT hockey title
A DETERMINED India claimed their fifth Hero Asian Champions Trophy title with a fighting 1-0 victory over hosts China here on Tuesday, completing a display of absolute dominance in the tournament in which they won all their matches.
Expanded CL season and Rodri warning
MANCHESTER City are braced for their Champions League reunion with Inter Milan at the start of an expanded tournament that will be “so tough” for the 2023 winners.
Chasing his red-ball dream, keeper-batter Jaker lands in India
POSTED as a Naik with Bangladesh Army, Showkat Ali of Habiganj district in Sylhet division, Bangladesh was not fond of cricket. Instead, he liked football.
Rahul or Sarfaraz: Middle-order conundrum
Captain Rohit hints at senior batter’s return in the first Test against Bangladesh starting in Chennai on Thursday