There are several factors that influence the effectiveness of a placebo medical treatment. The qualifications of the person handing it over help - a placebo works better coming from a doctor than coming from your mum. Inconvenience or discomfort will help too, for instance placebo injections are much more effective than placebo tablets.
Describing the treatment as "innovative" will give it a bit more fake zing. Some science that you don't understand is good too. And, obviously, the more expensive it is, the better.
All that is by way of introducing the subject of ketone drinks, the current buzz-substance in sports nutrition. If I'd been challenged to devise a placebo for cyclists, I'd have been very proud if ketones was what I'd come up with.
Wildly expensive, disgusting to drink, scientifically difficult to explain, and provided by doctors from teams with big research budgets.
And while I don't know for sure because no one has done the research, I'd suggest that multiple calls for a product to be banned would also add greatly to any placebo effect. Ketone drinks are placebo perfection.
Of course, none of that means that ketones don't work. It just means that figuring out whether there is any genuine physiological effect based on nothing other than rider anecdotes is going to be very difficult.
This story is from the June 20, 2024 edition of Cycling Weekly.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the June 20, 2024 edition of Cycling Weekly.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
CLASSIC BIKE - CHESINI CHALLENGE
In fair Verona, where we lay our scene...
Tour de I'Avenir
When the race ended in Paris, winner Mino Denti enjoyed a victory lap of the famous Parc des Princes velodrome
'I once thought ketones were so good they'd rendered training obsolete'
The deeper your pockets, the better the placebo effect
UK SCENE - NATIONAL 10-MILE RECORD POSTED
But Leon Atkins says he can go even faster...
AN EXPERT'S TAKE ON... PEAKING
We ask a scientist how to hit your peak bang on time
LOSING IT VS GETTING IT BACK
Time off the bike is the enemy of fitness but how bad is the damage and how best to reverse it? James Shrubsall investigates the science of detraining and retraining
RIDDEN AND REVIEWED - GIANT TCR ADVANCED SL O ₤11.999
A superlative climber that also flies on the flat
Five things you need to know about...PINARELLO DOGMA F from £12,600
Another update for the Pinarello Dogma, and just in time for this year's Tour
MEET THE MAKER NEILSON POWLESS AND HIS DAD JACK
The US rider and his Ironman champ dad tell Chris Marshall-Bell about their Indigenous American ancestry and fun-first training ethos
THE TOUR'S LEFT-FIELD TURN
Stage nine of the Tour de France features 32km on the white roads of the Champagne region. Steve Shrubsall grabs his gravel bike to sample what lies in wait for the peloton