Unmindful of the price he has to pay, Justice Karnan continues the fight against his brother judges The Week brings to you what is on the maverick judge's mind
About three weeks ago, I rang up Justice Chinnaswamy Swaminathan Karnan, sitting judge of the Calcutta High Court, requesting an interview. “I am out of station now. I will consider whether to give you an interview or not after I return,” he replied.
Justice Karnan has been engaged in a bitter legal battle with the Supreme Court. A seven-member Constitution Bench of the apex court on February 8, 2017 stripped him of all his judicial powers and asked for an explanation about the allegations of corruption he raised against judges of the Supreme Court and the Madras High Court. Justice Karnan retaliated by issuing a contempt notice to the seven judges. Subsequently, the Supreme Court ordered Justice Karnan to be medically examined to know whether he was “feigning mental imbalance” and submit the report by May 8. Within hours of the order, Justice Karnan asked the Delhi Police to get the seven judges examined by a psychiatric board.
Is he insane? I wondered. But he seemed perfectly all right when I talked to him over the phone. I again called him up for the appointment. This time, the judge burst into laughter. “Why would you like to interview me? The Supreme Court thinks I have lost my mental balance,” he said.
“Your lordship, I would like to see for myself,” I replied.
Justice Karnan handed over the phone to his secretary and I got an appointment for May 4, the same day the medical team mandated by the Supreme Court was scheduled to examine him. When I reached his sprawling apartment in the plush New Town area of Kolkata, which also functions as his makeshift office, a large media contingent was already present. I saw Justice Karnan in the corridor, dressed in a white shirt and dhoti, looking a little tense.
“Do you know where are the doctors and the police team accompanying them?” asked Justice Karnan.
Bu hikaye THE WEEK dergisinin May 21, 2017 sayısından alınmıştır.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Giriş Yap
Bu hikaye THE WEEK dergisinin May 21, 2017 sayısından alınmıştır.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Giriş Yap
William Dalrymple goes further back
Indian readers have long known William Dalrymple as the chronicler nonpareil of India in the early years of the British raj. His latest book, The Golden Road, is a striking departure, since it takes him to a period from about the third century BC to the 12th-13th centuries CE.
The bleat from the street
What with all the apps delivering straight to one’s doorstep, the supermarkets, the food halls and even the occasional (super-expensive) pop-up thela (cart) offering the woke from field-to-fork option, the good old veggie-market/mandi has fallen off my regular beat.
Courage and conviction
Justice A.M. Ahmadi's biography by his granddaughter brings out behind-the-scenes tension in the Supreme Court as it dealt with the Babri Masjid demolition case
EPIC ENTERPRISE
Gowri Ramnarayan's translation of Ponniyin Selvan brings a fresh perspective to her grandfather's magnum opus
Upgrade your jeans
If you don’t live in the top four-five northern states of India, winter means little else than a pair of jeans. I live in Mumbai, where only mad people wear jeans throughout the year. High temperatures and extreme levels of humidity ensure we go to work in mulmul salwars, cotton pants, or, if you are lucky like me, wear shorts every day.
Garden by the sea
When Kozhikode beach became a fertile ground for ideas with Manorama Hortus
RECRUITERS SPEAK
Industry requirements and selection criteria of management graduates
MORAL COMPASS
The need to infuse ethics into India's MBA landscape
B-SCHOOLS SHOULD UNDERSTAND THAT INDIAN ECONOMY IS GOING TO WITNESS A TREMENDOUS GROWTH
INTERVIEW - Prof DEBASHIS CHATTERJEE, director, Indian Institute of Management, Kozhikode
COURSE CORRECTION
India's best b-schools are navigating tumultuous times. Hurdles include lower salaries offered to their graduates and students misusing AI
