Why rape-murder cases are collapsing in higher courts
The Times of India Mumbai|November 13, 2022
In case after case, lapses in investigation and prosecution have led to acquittals. For the innocent, this means years lost to prison while for victims' families, it's a dead end in their quest for justice Prem Bisht
Himanshi Dhawan@timesgroup.com
Why rape-murder cases are collapsing in higher courts

Litigation head Project 39A, that works on death penalty reform, says that when individuals are acquitted at the SC appeal stage such as in the Chhawla case, the only remedy possible is filing a review petition, which goes before the same judges. "There are limited grounds to succeed in such a petition since it would have to be shown that there were errors apparent on the record," she says.

Re-investigation is not possible at this stage, says Borwankar, though strictures and disciplinary proceedings can be initiated against investigating officers.

Criminal lawyer Rebecca John described the apex court judgment as a telling commentary on faulty investigation procedures. "For far too long we have lowered our standards of proof without reasonable doubt. As a woman and a lawyer, I am affronted when police frame people who may be innocent or when a shoddy investigation ends up in acquittals. This is unfair, both to the accused who have been incarcerated for long years and the victim's family."

Nowhere was it more clear than in August this year when the Madhya Pradesh high court set a man free after a decade in prison for the rape and murder of his stepmother.

While acquitting the man, the court said it appeared that "after arresting the appellant and completing the formalities of collecting the evidence, the investigating officer has literally slept over the forensic reports." No effort had been made to get DNA profiling done, and it might have "led to sheer injustice, not only to the appellant but also to the deceased."

SHODDY INVESTIGATION

Bu hikaye The Times of India Mumbai dergisinin November 13, 2022 sayısından alınmıştır.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

Bu hikaye The Times of India Mumbai dergisinin November 13, 2022 sayısından alınmıştır.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

THE TIMES OF INDIA MUMBAI DERGISINDEN DAHA FAZLA HIKAYETümünü görüntüle
US soccer scrubs Islamic emblem from Iran flag
The Times of India Mumbai

US soccer scrubs Islamic emblem from Iran flag

The federation said in a statement Sunday that it decided to forego the official flag on social media accounts to show “support for the women in Iran fighting for basic human rights.”

time-read
2 dak  |
November 28, 2022
Pyar Ke Saat Vachan Dharam Patnii begins on TV tonight
The Times of India Mumbai

Pyar Ke Saat Vachan Dharam Patnii begins on TV tonight

What happens when kismet takes over the lives of two couples belonging to two different sections of society?

time-read
1 min  |
November 28, 2022
Arijit serenades music lovers in Mumbai
The Times of India Mumbai

Arijit serenades music lovers in Mumbai

Arijit Singh casts a spell with his voice

time-read
2 dak  |
November 28, 2022
ARGENTINA LIVE TO FIGHT ANOTHER DAY
The Times of India Mumbai

ARGENTINA LIVE TO FIGHT ANOTHER DAY

Messi's Strike Rattles Mexico And Lusail, Brings Team Back From The Brink

time-read
4 dak  |
November 28, 2022
Costa Rica come alive
The Times of India Mumbai

Costa Rica come alive

Los Ticos Stun Japan With Late Fuller Winner

time-read
1 min  |
November 28, 2022
Morocco's moment under the sun
The Times of India Mumbai

Morocco's moment under the sun

Inspired Atlas Lions Shock Belgium For First WC Win In 24 Years

time-read
3 dak  |
November 28, 2022
ON YOUR MARK, GET SET, SOAR
The Times of India Mumbai

ON YOUR MARK, GET SET, SOAR

Athletics Icon Usha Set To Become First Woman President Of IOA

time-read
2 dak  |
November 28, 2022
Industry body calls for slower rate hikes
The Times of India Mumbai

Industry body calls for slower rate hikes

CII Asks RBI To Moderate Pace Of Raising Repo As Global Woes May Impact Growth

time-read
2 dak  |
November 28, 2022
The Times of India Mumbai

Insurance reforms may see PE funding surge in sector

Irdai Raises Investment Cap, Allows PEs To Be Promoters

time-read
1 min  |
November 28, 2022
Cut ties with child-killing regime, Khamenei's niece tells world, held
The Times of India Mumbai

Cut ties with child-killing regime, Khamenei's niece tells world, held

Iranian authorities have arrested a niece of supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei after she recorded a video describing the authorities led by her uncle as a “murderous and child-killing regime”.

time-read
1 min  |
November 28, 2022