Delhi's dilemma

Bangladesh's request for the extradition of its former prime minister, Sheikh Hasina from India marks a pivotal moment in South Asian diplomacy.

This demand, rooted in allegations of severe crimes, presents India with a challenging decision that extends beyond legal obligations into the realms of regional stability and political strategy. The stakes are high, not just for bilateral relations but also for domestic politics in India, where any perceived misstep could spark debates about national interests and ethical responsibilities. The backdrop of this situation is a politically volatile Bangladesh, grappling with the aftermath of violent protests that led to Sheikh Hasina's overthrow and the more recent atrocities on its minority Hindu population. While the interim government of Mohammad Yunus frames its request as a pursuit of justice, the timing and nature of the charges raise questions about political motives. In a region where judicial processes often overlap with vendetta, this move risks deepening divisions within Bangladesh and fueling further unrest. For India, the decision on whether or not to extradite the former leader is fraught with complexities. Granting the request could be seen as aligning with Bangladesh's interim government accused of failing to protect its minorities and also potentially alienating Bangladeshis who remain loyal to the ousted leader. On the other hand, refusing to comply risks straining ties with Dhaka, which could have repercussions on trade, border security, and regional cooperation, with the rider that these could possibly impact Bangladesh more than it does India.