يحاول ذهب - حر
The great debate
September 2023
|Golf Monthly
Nick Bonfield explores the concept of greatness in professional golf and ponders how it should be defined

The concept of greatness is one that permeates all areas of professional sport - players strive for it, fans heatedly debate it and legacies are forged because of it. Of course, greatness is a broad concept and its definition will vary based on the subject matter, but is it even something that can be objectively defined? If so, what constitutes greatness in professional golf?
I had this discussion with GM contributor Wayne Riley recently and it occurred to me it was a topic that warranted further thought. Like me, he feels the word 'great' is used too often, so we set about attempting to define it in a golfing context. It quickly became clear how challenging it would be.
Every time we thought we'd managed it, a player would pop into our minds who threw our methodology into question. And how do you standardise achievements in a game that's changed markedly since the first Open Championship in 1860? There's no doubt it's a tricky undertaking, but in this piece, I'll attempt to establish if greatness can be systematically defined in golf, or whether we have to judge each person on a case-by-case basis.
Major Championships
Most, understandably, believe the starting point for defining greatness is Major Championships; that you simply can't be considered a premier player if you haven't got over the line at least once in one of golf's big four tournaments. But is this fair and, if so, how many Major titles is the minimum requirement?
هذه القصة من طبعة September 2023 من Golf Monthly.
اشترك في Magzter GOLD للوصول إلى آلاف القصص المتميزة المنسقة، وأكثر من 9000 مجلة وصحيفة.
هل أنت مشترك بالفعل؟ تسجيل الدخول
المزيد من القصص من Golf Monthly

Golf Monthly
ODYSSEY AI-ONE SQUARE 2 SQUARE MAX 1 PUTTER £369
Despite releasing the majority of its Square 2 Square putter range towards the back end of 2024, Odyssey has just extended the family with the most stable model yet.
2 mins
Summer 2025

Golf Monthly
Richie Ramsay
The four-time DP World Tour winner suggests some simple, practical ways to help you think smarter and play better
3 mins
Summer 2025

Golf Monthly
BLAZING A TRAIL
Argentinian Roberto De Vicenzo was a pioneering professional who won more than 200 times in his career, with his greatest triumph of all coming at Hoylake in the summer of 1967...
8 mins
Summer 2025

Golf Monthly
PLAYERS' DISTANCE IRONS
The players' distance iron category is a very interesting equipment space where all manner of different player types seem to converge.
5 mins
Summer 2025

Golf Monthly
MOVING ON UP
Laurie Canter has been through an awful lot over the past few years. Here, he tells Sam De'Ath about his remarkable journey from LIV Golf to the world's top 50....
9 mins
Summer 2025

Golf Monthly
Stars of the show
Jeremy Ellwood attempts to narrow it down to a handful of his most memorable par 3s from the thousands he's played over the last 45 years
7 mins
Summer 2025

Golf Monthly
A SUPERB 2025 FOR SRIXON
Given that it is your only point of contact with the club as you swing, finding the right grip is essential.
2 mins
Summer 2025

Golf Monthly
What is my best option when I face a tight greenside lie?
Stand fairly close to the ball in order to get the handle more vertical, so that only the toe end of the sole is in contact with the ground.
1 min
Summer 2025

Golf Monthly
East Kent coast
I've been travelling south to play golf on the Kent coast for over 20 years now.
3 mins
Summer 2025

Golf Monthly
How to read any green well
Reading a green starts way before you reach the putting surface, as there is so much information you can take in from the walk towards your ball.
1 mins
Summer 2025