Foremost in resolving the Tata-Mistry dispute is whether ‘corporate democracy’ overrides all other issues, notably independence of directors.
The Tata-Mistry imbroglio has shaken the roots of the Indian corporate sector with regard to two important factors. First, the Tata group, being one of the most reputed corporate groups in India, has suffered an erosion of its brand value. The National Company Law Tribunal observed that even the country’s image may be affected. Second, for the first time, the chairman of various publicly listed companies was sought to be removed as a director on the ground that he has lost the confidence of the principal shareholder.
While allegations and counter allegations may be probed by the appropriate regulatory authorities based on documented evidence, critical issues need to be considered in the context of corporate governance, particularly the sanctity of protecting the independence of directors.
The foremost issue is whether the principle of ‘corporate democracy’ would override all other crucial issues, notably independence of directors, protection of interest of minority shareholders and principles of good governance.
Indeed, it was argued before the Bombay High Court by the counsel of the Tata group that the principle of corporate democracy alone should be applied to determine whether a director can be removed from the board. The counsel of the market regulator, Sebi, argued that Section 169 of the Companies Act, 2013 holds the field and allows removal of even an independent director by an ordinary resolution.
Prima facie Section 169 is clearly worded. While it permits the director sought to be removed to make a written representation to the shareholders and gives him an opportunity to be heard, a resolution passed by a simple majority at a shareholders’ meeting would decide the fate of the director.
This story is from the {{IssueName}} edition of {{MagazineName}}.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the {{IssueName}} edition of {{MagazineName}}.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Home-Cooked Meal Is Now Greatly Valued
The pandemic has also brought with it an improved focus on hygiene, use of technology in dining, rise of cloud kitchens and resurgence in popularity of Indian ingredients
Paytm 3.0 - Reaching Near Breakeven In Two Years
As of 2020, Vijay Shekhar Sharma’s super app for financial services had run up losses in thousands of crores. Now, as digital payments gets yet another boost courtesy Covid-19, he’s hopeful of reaching near breakeven in two years
THE PANDEMIC HAS CAUSED WOMEN GREATER LABOUR PAIN
Covid-19 has shown that women are more likely to face the brunt of job losses than men, and find fewer opportunities when they want to resume. That apart, several have to deal with increased hours of unpaid work at home and even domestic abuse
LEADERSHIP WILL BE ABOUT SEEING THE BIGGER PICTURE
Leaders must not only guard their teams first during a crisis, but also deal with stakeholders with respect and dignity. And apart from pursuing business goals, they should remain committed to our planet and the environment
PHILANTHROPY SHOULD BE HUMBLE, BUT NOT MODEST
Apart from building a flexible and resilient framework for the future, philanthropists, civil society and the government must work in tandem so that every rupee is absorbed on the ground
INTEGRATED HEALTH CARE, TECH WILL DISRUPT SECTOR
While clinical research will get a boost, having a skilled workforce and public spending on health care will be challenges in the near term
DIGITALISATION WILL HELP IN VALUE CREATION
As the pandemic brings technology and innovation to the core of business and daily life, the next decade will see about 150 million digital-first families in India
Industry 4.0: Climate Revolution?
Augmenting sustainability alongside digital capabilities is an economic, competitive and global opportunity for India’s businesses, but regulations need to reflect intent
EV Dream Still Miles Away
Electric vehicles have remained a buzzword in India for years. But not much has moved on ground due to high upfront costs, range anxiety and charging infrastructure
Living Waters
A virus has caused us to scramble for oxygen but our chokehold on the environment is slowly strangling the very waters that breathe life into us. The virus is a timely reminder: We are merely consumers, not producers of life’s breath on this planet