The Pick 'N' Mix Diet
New Zealand Listener|June 9 - 15 2018

A Stanford University study finds no biological reason to opt for one weight-loss diet over another.

Nicky Pellegrino
The Pick 'N' Mix Diet

The low-carb, high-fat ketogenic diet is all the rage. So if you want to lose weight and be healthier should you be on it? Or would you be better to go paleo, vegan, low-fat or sugar-free, or eat according to your blood type or genes? Never has there been so much confusion about the best way to fuel our bodies, and meanwhile we keep getting fatter.

Christopher Gardner, the director of nutrition studies at Stanford University in California, had a couple of theories about why some diets might work for certain people and not others. The first was related to genes. Three genotypes had been identified that appeared, from a small study of overweight women, to influence whether they shed more kilos on a low-fat or a low-carb diet.

Gardner embarked on a second, larger trial with 609 overweight adults aged 18 to 50 who cut back on fat or carbs for a year depending on their genotype. All were encouraged to eat the healthiest possible versions of low-fat or low-carb diets, avoiding sugar and refined grains. They attended 22 nutrition sessions, were taught to eat mindfully, avoid highly processed foods, consume lots of vegetables and prepare meals at home. They weren’t instructed to cut or count calories.

By the end of the trial, people in both of the groups lost an average of 5-6kg – it made no difference which eating plan they followed or what genotype they had.

The publication of Gardner’s Dietfits study earlier this year resulted in headlines around the world suggesting that personalised diets don’t work and DNA-matching makes no difference. But Gardner says it’s not as simple as that.

“Here’s the problem: there are dozens, maybe hundreds, of genes related to obesity. There are so many that one study couldn’t possibly look at them all.”

This story is from the {{IssueName}} edition of {{MagazineName}}.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the {{IssueName}} edition of {{MagazineName}}.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM NEW ZEALAND LISTENERView all
First-world problem
New Zealand Listener

First-world problem

Harrowing tales of migrants attempting to enter the US highlight the political failure to fully tackle the problem.

time-read
3 mins  |
September 9, 2024
Applying intelligence to AI
New Zealand Listener

Applying intelligence to AI

I call it the 'Terminator Effect', based on the premise that thinking machines took over the world.

time-read
2 mins  |
September 9, 2024
Nazism rears its head
New Zealand Listener

Nazism rears its head

Smirky Höcke, with his penchant for waving with a suspiciously straight elbow and an open palm, won't get to be boss of either state.

time-read
2 mins  |
September 9, 2024
Staying ahead of the game
New Zealand Listener

Staying ahead of the game

Will the brave new world of bipartisanship that seems to be on offer with an Infrastructure Commission come to fruition?

time-read
4 mins  |
September 9, 2024
Grasping the nettle
New Zealand Listener

Grasping the nettle

Broccoli is horrible. It smells, when being cooked, like cat pee.

time-read
3 mins  |
September 9, 2024
Hangry? Eat breakfast
New Zealand Listener

Hangry? Eat breakfast

People who don't break their fast first thing in the morning report the least life satisfaction.

time-read
3 mins  |
September 9, 2024
Chemical reaction
New Zealand Listener

Chemical reaction

Nitrates in processed meats are well known to cause harm, but consumed from plant sources, their effect is quite different.

time-read
4 mins  |
September 9, 2024
Me and my guitar
New Zealand Listener

Me and my guitar

Australian guitarist Karin Schaupp sticks to the familiar for her Dunedin concerts.

time-read
2 mins  |
September 9, 2024
Time is on my side
New Zealand Listener

Time is on my side

Age does not weary some of our much-loved musicians but what keeps them on the road?

time-read
7 mins  |
September 9, 2024
The kids are not alright
New Zealand Listener

The kids are not alright

Nuanced account details how China's blessed generation has been replaced by one consumed by fear and hopelessness.

time-read
4 mins  |
September 9, 2024