Raghuram Rajan, who held powerful positions in the Congress government, has recently been critical of the PLI scheme, suggesting that India should focus on services rather than manufacturing.
He co-authored a piece in TOI (‘Making in India. But how?’ bit.ly/3RhCH2v) critiquing PLI. But there are several problems with that argument.
He cites the most expensive smartphone in the world and goes on to argue that the 14 PLI schemes are some kind of ill-planned largesse that represents short-term thinking, forcing consumers to pay more without any upside.
Here is a fact check.
That consumers are paying more due to higher taxes is factually incorrect. That applies to very few.
The iPhone model for which he cites a 40% price difference between India and Chicago, constitutes less than 0.5% of the 300 million mobile phones sold in India. Customs duty plus GST are the taxes.
In 2014-15, after UPA’s Nokia debacle, India was forced to import nearly 80% of mobile phones.
Today, nearly 97% of all phones sold in India are made in India.
So, 97% consumers don’t pay the taxes – customs duties – Rajan says they do.
Less than 3% consumers – the richest of the rich – pay.
Rajan’s argument is akin to suggesting that consumers pay more for scooters in India because the government levies customs duty on imported Rolls Royce cars. Rajan seems to suggest that PLI is a largesse aimed at foreign companies. Again, not true. PLI complements the Phased Manufacturing Programme (PMP) of 2017, aimed at import substitution. PLI also aims to build exports from India.
This story is from the {{IssueName}} edition of {{MagazineName}}.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the {{IssueName}} edition of {{MagazineName}}.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Tollywood was happy hunting turf for conman
Kept Database Of Mobile Nos. Of Film Celebs
State-funded Metro to chug into RGIA in 3 yrs
Residents’ Plea To KTR To Extend Other Rail Lines
Rajiv Makhni becomes the face of smart tech luggage with proximity indicator
The VIP SmarTech series, a range of smart travel gear, keeps you connected with your luggage via your smartphone
I want to reach out to Samantha and tell her that if I can make it, so can you, says Vikram Bhatt
The filmmaker opens up about his 18-year-long battle with fibromyalgia, a chronic disorder that causes widespread muscle pain
Rain ruins second ODI
The match was reduced to 29-overs-a-side as the first interruption caused a four-hour break. India were 22 for no loss in the fifth over at that time.
Croatia come in hard, show Canada the exit
After their dour opening draw with Morocco had instigated a post-mortem into whether this Croatia side lacked a killer instinct, Kramaric and Marko Livaja found the net before the break to take the wind out of Canada’s sails.
Denmark calls on Euro 2020, Eriksen experience
Denmark has been here before.
Ronaldo targets KO berth
Win Vs Uruguay Will Help Portugal Advance With A Game To Spare
Govt doubles large aircraft wet lease period to 1 yr
Accordingly, IndiGo can now wet lease two twin aisles to operate flights between Delhi/Mumbai and Istanbul for a year.
Deuba's party emerges as single largest party in poll
Elections to the House of Representatives and seven provincial assemblies were held on November 20.
