試す 金 - 無料
An Awkward Silence
The Caravan
|March 2017
Massive layoffs at newspapers expose professional conditions that undermine the public sphere / Media

The historian Mukul Kesavan’s column in The Telegraph on 12 February was titled “A Delicate Balance: The state of the fourth estate.” In it, Kesavan begins by saying that “Midway through Narendra Modi’s term in office … [a]s someone who writes opinion pieces, I can report that the papers I write for haven’t suddenly begun to censor me. No edit desk has returned a copy with sentences underlined in red because it has felt uneasy with the political implications of something I had written.” Then, he moves on to less rosy thoughts: “the intimidation of reporters and correspondents is more commonplace and easier to cite,” and “the NDA government and the prime minister and the BJP’s online army exert real and concerted pressure on liberal journalists.” Kesavan observes at one point, rightly, that it is “increasingly the case that journalists who don’t enjoy the institutional shelter that big newspapers supply, are constrained and unfree.”
Less than a fortnight earlier, the ABP Group, which owns The Telegraph and the Bengali-language Anandabazar Patrika, notified hundreds of staff at its papers that they were being laid off. This was preceded by a similar exercise at the Hindustan Times a month earlier, with four editions and three bureaus being shut down. Kesavan, in over 1,200 words of writing, does not find space for the slightest mention of any of this. If The Telegraph’s edit desk did not encourage such wilful and convenient blindness, Kesavan must have taken the initiative himself.
このストーリーは、The Caravan の March 2017 版からのものです。
Magzter GOLD を購読すると、厳選された何千ものプレミアム記事や、9,500 以上の雑誌や新聞にアクセスできます。
すでに購読者ですか? サインイン
The Caravan からのその他のストーリー

The Caravan
THE RSS DOES NOT EXIST
MAPPING THE HIDDEN STRUCTURE OF AN UNACCOUNTABLE ORGANISATION
3 mins
July 2025

The Caravan
Wishing for a Hindu War
Modi's Pakistan policy bears Golwalkar's imprint
10 mins
July 2025

The Caravan
ROADS to RUIN
Megaprojects in the Northeast cannot make up for decades of neglect
27 mins
July 2025

The Caravan
Four Deaths and No Answers in Kulgam
Kashmir police silences questions as bodies emerge from the Veshaw River
20 mins
July 2025

The Caravan
Tourism as Colonialism
The commodification of tribal lives in India / Communities
5 mins
July 2025

The Caravan
Someone Else's Problem
Waste and labour in urban South Asia
19 mins
July 2025

The Caravan
Priyamvada Natarajan: "The kick you get from making predictions"
A leading astrophysicist on supermassive black holes and her drive to do science / Science
17 mins
July 2025

The Caravan
MAKING A MEASURE
The history of the Human Development project
15 mins
July 2025

The Caravan
Foggy Slope to Armageddon
The first South Asian crisis of the third nuclear age /Conflict
7 mins
July 2025

The Caravan
A United Front
What the Indian media gets wrong about Modi and Trump, and Modi and the world / Politics
9 mins
July 2025